Superhuman Website Review: How not to design a website(

2 months ago from Lauren Holliday,

  • Andrew C, 2 months ago

    Even though I agree with a lot of the feedback posted here I find the vast majority of the comments posted in this teardown to be too juvenile and not constructive enough to be helpful.

    3 points
    • Lauren Holliday, 2 months ago

      It's part of a blog post I'm writing, in which I dive deep into specific actionable feedback for them. I was sharing a sneak peek.

      0 points
      • Jake FlemingJake Fleming, 1 month ago

        I'm curious what the underlying goal of your blog post is. If it is to get the attention of these companies so that they might hire you some day, the tone seems quite harsh. The review was pretty hard to get through, and not because the website is meh.

        0 points
      • Andrew C, 1 month ago

        Imagine you were talking directly to the designer and engineer who made this. Would you laugh out loud at them for using stock photos? Or would you ask why they chose those photos and provide alternatives to help improve the design?

        Even if your blog post goes in to this you can’t rely on someone reading a tear down AND a long-form blog post.

        It’s your content at the end of the day, but I’d be much less receptive or outright hostile to someone being a jerk in a design critique.

        0 points