MIT website redesign(web.mit.edu)

over 3 years ago from Alexander Stocker, Founder

  • Daniel GoldenDaniel Golden, over 3 years ago

    This comment is rude and unhelpful. If the delete comment functionality for mods was working rn it would be deleted.

    6 points
    • Account deleted over 3 years ago

      I listed why I thought it was bad below that comment, and nobody seems to have rebuked any of those points. This reminds me of dribbble. People only want feedback if it's good.

      4 points
      • C W, over 3 years ago

        I think most designers welcome negative feedback, we just insist on being treated with respect while being given said feedback. Calling something terrible, or your original comment which simply says you think it's bad without expanding, those are extremely negative ways of providing constructive criticism and I think you probably know that.

        Maybe you're having a bad day, but that doesn't mean you can act like a dick and break this sites rules. Would you use those words or talk that way in a design review IRL? I highly doubt it.

        3 points
        • Account deleted over 3 years ago

          I absolutely would use those words if a senior designer presented that to me. If it was junior I would probably give them advice on how to make it better. I genuinely thought it was so bad that it didn't need further explanation, but I guess I was wrong about that.

          0 points