Eli Schiff - Dystopic Pipes(elischiff.com)

6 years ago from Marco Scannadinari, Web developer

  • Andrew Simchik, 6 years ago

    I didn't intend my response to come off as snarky; I was genuinely puzzled, and I appreciate the lengthy reply on your part. I certainly don't think Eli is an unimpeachable voice on design -- just an entertaining one who makes some good points but (like any critic) isn't right about everything. Criticizing and disagreeing with him is totally reasonable and worthwhile; it's just that most of the responses I see to his pieces don't engage with them at all, just express the belief that "nobody cares" about the stuff he's criticizing, which seems patently false.

    0 points