Designer News
Where the design community meets.
8 years ago from Julian Lengfelder, Project & Studiomanagement @yccpgroup + Freelance Front End Designer
I think the implementation doesn't fit, but Material is incredibly flexible and can accommodate iOS standard elements. In this particular case, the action bar should not be separated like an Android app. One of the many things Android fans have been upset about since (at least) last November is the inconsistency between product design teams at Google. I'm not sure if this is another case of that happening, but it is a possibility.
On another (selfish and petty) note, after years and years of iOS ports on Android, I am slightly happy to see it go the other way for once.
Completely agree - Material Design is definitely flexible enough to accommodate iOS conventions. It's a little telling that they avoided that path with this app, though...
Designer News
Where the design community meets.
Designer News is a large, global community of people working or interested in design and technology.
Have feedback?
I do like Material Design. But based on these two screenshots, this looks exactly like an Android app.
That's not necessarily bad, but it's... interesting that Google is changing all their products on competing devices to suit their own platform's design language. I personally don't think it fits, and could be a dangerous path to go down.
I just thank god Microsoft didn't do this with OneNote/Office apps.