Spotifree—OS X App for Muting Spotify Ads(

over 7 years ago from Kevin Rabinovich, Ideas, youth, tech, design, & education

  • Sebastiaan de WithSebastiaan de With, over 7 years ago

    Classifying muting or blocking ads as 'piracy' is a bit of a stretch, wouldn't you say? Is it also piracy if I turn the volume off while ads play? Is it piracy if I leave the room?

    15 points
    • Erik Friberg, over 7 years ago (edited over 7 years ago )

      Yes off course it's a bit of a stretch to define it as piracy, does stealing sound better? It's like buying CDs, copy them and then return them back to the store. You might technically not do anything illegal but you are effectively avoiding compensating the creators(and distributors and the store). I still fail to see how this belongs to designer news however you define it.

      3 points
      • Jesse C.Jesse C., over 7 years ago

        Also, how does it fair as far as being moral, empathetic, etc.? As designers, do we not at least strive to show empathy, understanding, and the like. Like you said, maybe it's not 'illegal', but is it something you would like done to yourself?

        0 points
        • Eric REric R, over 7 years ago

          Also, how does it fair as far as being moral, empathetic, etc.?

          I don't think its that much different from using AdBlock in your browser. By using that, a ton of sites that use Ads as the main source of revenue are now making nothing.

          The difference here of course is that Spotify offers a paid plan to turn off ads, unlike most websites that use ads.

          Also, if this just mutes the ad, doesn't the ad still run and count as an impression? I would assume they aren't actually losing any ad revenue through this if it works like that.

          0 points